RIIO3 Call for Evidence on ET3 Business Plans
Dear Ofgem,
In this response we set out our views on two specific issues with the Electricity Transmission
Business Plans where we have a particular interest and expertise – (1) SF6 and (2) losses.
PART ONE: SF6
This has been a long-standing area of focus for Sustainability First building on our review of the ED2
SF6 Strategies and our subsequent substantive report (through Grid Edge Policy) on “Green Grids:
Tackling SF6 Emissions on GB Electricity Networks” which explored the SF6 challenge in depth and
which we have shared previously with Ofgem. We would encourage Ofgem colleagues to revisit that
report as they review the company proposals in this area. In summary we called for a laser like focus on reducing leakage from existing equipment and close working with manufacturers to develop safe alternatives to SF6. We highlighted the potential role of monitoring and analytics to help in managing leakage and in more accurate reporting.
On availability of new equipment, we highlighted the impact that the updated EU F-Gas Regulation
could have for European manufacturers and hence the supply chain in GB for high voltage
switchgear and suitable SF6 alternatives. This remains a vital matter for GB in the ET3 period given
the scale of new investment required by all three GB transmission companies to deliver on the
Government’s Clean Power 2030 Action Plan.
As well as introducing a ban on SF6, the EU F-Gas Regulation also explicitly banned fluoronitriles and
F-Gases with a GWP3 >1, albeit all subject to various derogations. On the face of it this would
preclude most of the alternatives that have been deployed to date by the transmission networks.
How the derogations will be applied remains unclear. Irrespective of any thinking on future updates
to the UK F-Gas Regulations, and with a firm eye to Clean Power 2030, we would expect the companies (and also Ofgem in line with its Growth Duty) to be in active discussion with government (both DESNZ and DEFRA) on what, if any, supply-chain issues might arise regarding ready-access to suitable SF6-free high voltage transmission equipment in the ET3 period.
The company Plans give no indication that these conversations are taking place and, indeed, make no mention at all of the EU FGas Regulation. This should be a priority for Ofgem to explore with the networks. Having now reviewed the ET Business Plans, we have raised various concerns and detailed proposals in our full response document available here.
PART TWO: LOSSES
In our response to the SSMC, we flagged that we were concerned by the complete absence of any
reference to the need to consider electricity losses in transmission. We were therefore pleased that SSMD Ofgem strongly reinforced the importance of losses.
Ofgem noted that at ET2 the TOs each included a Transmission Losses Strategy in their business
plans, and were required to incorporate transmission losses into their EAPs and report annually on
transmission losses as part of their AER. ForE T3 Ofgem said they would specifically target this area in their business plan assessment and provide comment on it in their Draft Determinations. We hope that they will honour this commitment. Having now reviewed the ET Business Plans, we point out some significant drawbacks and shortcomings that we believe need to adressed. You can find all of our points and recommendations in the response document here.
We hope that our reflections on these two specific aspects of the ET3 Business Plans are helpful and
would be happy to discuss them further.