Your browser is out of date. Some of the content on this site will not work properly as a result.
Upgrade your browser for a faster, better, and safer web experience.

Re: A review of Ofgem – Call for evidence

In recent years the legitimacy of regulators has been called into question alongside the market philosophies that underpin them. But given the substantial and complex upcoming changes in the energy sector we do not think that now is the time for radical changes to Ofgem.   That said, there is scope to streamline Ofgem’s duties, improve transparency and accountability for decision making, as well as strengthen consumer protections especially by improving the way Ofgem works.

Duties and decision-making

We advocate for:   

  • A strengthening of Ofgem’s primary objective and associated guidance to protect consumer interests – in particular strengthening consumer interests relative to competition and a sharper focus on low income and vulnerable consumers, small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs), and future consumers.
  • A new citizens interest duty which could include resilience, safety and sustainable growth and be flexible to emerging concerns. There is precedent for this with other regulators. This would result in Ofgem giving greater consideration to social value in decision-making, striving to deliver best value for citizens, not just lowest cost for energy customers.
  • A new ‘thriving environment duty’ – capturing the existing net zero duty and a new duty to conserve, enhance and restore the natural environment in line with the government’s pledge to halt the decline in species populations by 2030 and to reverse this decline by 2042. The absence of a nature and wildlife duty is at odds with government’s wider commitments and consumer trends. It risks undermining long-term sustainable growth and being counter-productive to public acceptance of the energy transition.
  • Greater transparency around how Ofgem makes its decisions including how it makes trade-offs between different duties, evidence, and consumer insight. There’s a body of research that suggests the process of decision making and transparency around how decisions are made is as important as the decisions themselves to building public trust, acceptance and the legitimacy of the energy sector.
  • A requirement for Ofgem to document the alternatives to competition that it has considered when carrying out its duties.

Enhanced accountability 
To strengthen scrutiny and the regulator’s accountability we propose: 

  • Ofgem holds regular open public hearings where it hears directly from members of the public and key stakeholder groups and responds to their concerns.
  • Improvements to Ofgem’s annual reporting such as: making its annual report more accessible; updating performance metrics including a new stakeholder satisfaction metric; being clear what’s new and what’s not in its list of achievements and how many years it has been working on an issue; capturing lessons lesson from the past and how improvements have been made as a result.
  • Quarterly meetings between Ofgem senior leaders and consumer and civil society groups. Regular meetings with Ofgem’s CEO used to happen but appear to have petered out.

Improving consumer outcomes 
We propose a range of ways in which Ofgem could work smarter to improve consumer outcomes and support others in their work. These include: 

  • Ofgem putting greater weight on customer and public insight in its decision making and improving the quality of its own stakeholder engagement. As well as helping to build trust and legitimacy in the energy sector this could also help the regulator navigate some of the trickier trade-offs between its duties.
  • The publication of Ofgem’s consumer research all together with an insight hub on its website – in line with open data so that others can easily use it.
  • A quarterly open webinar where Ofgem, CitA, the Energy Ombudsman and other organisations share emerging trends in customer complaints/ contacts. This would support consumer advocates in their work and build collaboration.
  • Better use of data and machine learning to support market monitoring, earlier intervention when there is poor practice and faster enforcement.
  • A requirement for the regulator to
    • a) horizon scan future risks and opportunities,
    • b) adopt a ‘preventative principle’, committing to take early action to prevent likely consumer harm rather than ‘wait and see’ before taking action,
    • c) report on how it is meeting the needs of future consumers including an energy retail strategic direction,
    • d) ‘Right first time’ regulation, rather than multiple consultations on the same issue over many years which is hugely resource intensive for all parties.
  • Ensuring its workforce is fit for the future. We highlight value in strengthening skills and knowledge on: digital and data; major projects delivery; whole systems thinking and ethics; investment in capital markets; and sustainability including at Board level.
  • Ofgem continuing to strengthen is in-depth sector knowledge and institutional memory. The high turnover of staff exacerbates the information asymmetry between energy companies and the regulator, weakening the regulators’ ability to safeguard current and future consumers.  This also slows down decision making.
  • The importance of working with other regulators and with the new National Infrastructure and Service Transformation Authority (NISTA) to ensure that dependences with other sectors – digital, transport and water dependence on energy, energy dependence on digital – are fully taken into account in energy regulation and also that Ofgem should work to ensure that UK Regulators Network is fully supported.

Lastly we outline nine ways in which Ofgem can support sustainable growth, beyond minimising energy costs, keeping supply resilient and energy markets functioning effectively.

We provide more detail in our full response available here. 

future protections OFGEM Consultation Submissions

Want to find out how we can help your organisation?

Get in touch

Search our publications