Your browser is out of date. Some of the content on this site will not work properly as a result.
Upgrade your browser for a faster, better, and safer web experience.

A New Course For Water Regulation: The Cunliffe Review

Published in The UK Water Report. 

The Cunliffe review is a once in a generation opportunity to reset the water industry, its regulation and the water environment. As a former Number 10 environment advisor, I would say it’s something which only a new Government of a different political stamp could perhaps have attempted. Credit goes to Steve Reed for initiating it and his choice of Sir John Cunliffe, whose independence from past industry decisions and high-level CV gives him the credibility needed for the task.

The selection of the advisory panel appears well judged – albeit it should have been created sooner. Although some questions from the call for evidence seem odd – how organisations are meant to rank the three most important issues is an unhelpfully simplistic approach – the background material is extensive, and Sir John has done a good job so far.

As an independent utility think tank, we at Sustainability First have been working on these issues for a long time. Much of the material aligns with our analysis and thinking. There are however two major omissions.

First is the carbon footprint of water: the UK is committed to net zero and is struggling to meet its own interim carbon budgets. Water is heavy, moving it requires a lot of power. And the scale of new infrastructure required – and the type of infrastructure which the Environment Agency (EA) in particular favours (concrete, steel and chemicals intensive) – means the industry will have a quite unnecessarily high, and for many years growing, carbon footprint, possibly even after electricity is fully decarbonised. For an organisation which has the environment in its title , has a statutory sustainable development duty, and which has set itself a laudable internal net zero target, it is disappointing that the EA does not consider carbon as part of companies’ measured environmental performance on the sole basis that it is not regulated by them. There also is a missed opportunity to integrate carbon considerations more fully into regulatory decision making, including through transparent analysis and publication of impacts.

Second, the review appears to accept the case for more outcome-based regulation, around a reformed water framework directive approach – see SSWAN for an excellent analysis of the advantages of this. It also recognises that outcomes include both the environmental health of water bodies and their public health (e-coli etc. from sewage, and antibiotics and pathogens from intensive farming). But it is all but silent on the need to address and reform the deadweight of process regulation which has provided ample excuses for regulators and companies to ignore outcomes. Specific examples include the Environment Act target on end-of-pipe Phosphorous, the Government’s storm overflows targets and the (overinterpreted) Urban Wastewater Treatment directive.

Rather than attempt to provide thinking on all 73 questions, not to mention the 293 pages of documentation, it might be more helpful if I now suggest some areas covered in the Cunliffe material where we think it would be worth concentrating.

Spending water bill payer’s money more effectively  
As a nation, we are wasting money on water – from bill payers (including corporates), but also in some cases the exchequer. There is no cost effectiveness test for EA requirements – let alone cost benefit analysis – partly by law! The Government’s guidance to Ofwat is silent on how to manage trade-offs, and there is no guidance at all to the EA, so trade-offs are either ad hoc, or reflect the views/interpretations of unelected bodies. There is little join up with the related agendas of flood reduction, carbon (see above) or agricultural support. Near identical interventions on four parts of the same river may be funded from EA grant, natural flood management money, environmental stewardship and water company spend, with four different bureaucracies and four different outcome requirements.

The fact that ‘nature based’ approaches can deliver carbon fixing, flood risk management as well as water environmental benefits is largely ignored in practice. If we had one change to make on environmental regulation it would be to require a hierarchy for interventions – input control (stopping chemicals/wet wipes etc getting into sewage in the first place); nature based; hybrid and only then hard (‘grey’) solutions such as storm tanks and chemical treatment – and for the application of this hierarchy to take into account multiple benefits and disbenefits.

Simplifying and modernising water regulation 
Water regulation has grown by accretion. A new problem arises, we tack a new bit of regulation on top without examining the potential impact on the wider regulatory approach. This breeds complexity and is a major barrier to transparency and trust.

We need to take a radical step back and look at what we are trying to achieve and how best to do it – an obvious test would be: ‘is the regulator doing something which only it can do’, and ‘how can we ensure they are delivering for society’. For both Ofwat and the EA data interrogation and telemetry advances offer a real opportunity and could significantly reduce dependence on both process regulation and ‘comparative competition’. Both bodies need to step up here rather than pursuing yesterday’s models of regulation – Sustainability First work suggests that water regulation often lags technological advances by 7-8 years (from one ‘methodology statement’ for example, to the end of the next Price Review period). To address this, we would strongly advocate much more institutionalised flexibility within 5-year regulatory cycles (including the Water Industry National Environment Programme).

Strengthening local involvement and devolution 
We need to take the devolution agenda on board. Not just because of the Government’s significant local government and mayoral aspirations, but also because water is currently in large part a local service set nationally: it needs fundamentally to reconnect to communities. To our thinking it can best do this by handing these communities – or their elected representatives – some real power. Elected mayors and big unitary councils have an obvious part to play.

The Scottish model of negotiated agreements, while possibly not fully transferable, has a lot to teach us here as could experience of deliberative fora.  A more devolved approach would also enable better join up with the Government’s housing and growth agendas.

Ensuring intergenerational fairness  
We have argued that there has been an implicit compact for 25 years between regulators, government, companies and their investors, and consumer bodies to underplay the interests of the next generation. We are starting to pay the price for this in the PR24 price increases. Ofwat’s new requirement for long term delivery strategies and some parts of water resource planning is a good start, but we need a systematic approach across the piece.  This needs also to look at the impacts of climate change on aquatic ecosystems: to develop resilient ecosystems as much as protecting the status quo and develop waterways as biodiversity corridors.

To achieve this, we need a voice at the table for the long term. And we need a national conversation on key long-term issues such as acceptable standards of service with regards to drought risk, and how much we are prepared to pay to deliver these.

Aligning water infrastructure with national priorities 
I have already mentioned that water has a crucial role in supporting new housing. There are also other direct impacts on/from the government’s wider infrastructure ambitions: for example, Anglian Water have identified that how a potential hydrogen plant at Bacton is supplied will have major implications for the supply demand balance across the whole sub region. Water availability has also been a key factor in determining how rapidly Cambridge, with its nationally important science industries, can expand.
Less well recognised is the potential for competition between water infrastructure and energy, housing, transport, schools, hospitals, flood defences and prisons investments for the same supply chain and in some cases infrastructure finance. The new National Infrastructure Service and Transformation Authority has been set up to address this – but its placement within the Treasury could stymie its effectiveness.  Put simply, water cannot set its own requirements in isolation – the regulators need both to ensure we don’t simply generate internal supply chain inflation but also play their parts in prioritising our needs against those of the wider economy.

There is a lack of strategic planning for the sector, with each regulator and the companies having some responsibilities for planning but no overall coherent plan. Some form of wider strategic system planning (different to system operation!) function seems unavoidable – in the energy sector similar challenges led to the creation of the NESO (national energy system operator) which has planning responsibilities across the energy sector, explicitly aligned to deliver the government’s objectives.

Reforming governance and regulation structures 
Finally, the elephant in the room: we cannot now ignore what are usually termed ‘machinery of government’ changes. On the environment, it is hard to conclude that the inclusion of water regulation alongside waste regulation, industrial pollution control, fishing licences, navigation and flood defence in the EA, with Ofwat to a fair extent simply there to fund the EA’s views of its regulatory requirements and penalise underperformance is the best structure for the current and emerging pressures. If we are to move to outcome based joined up regulation aiming to achieve cost effective interventions by the industry it seems to us that we need wide cultural changes in regulation and industry: we doubt these can be achieved without structural changes even accepting the short-term disruption those will cause.

There is also a governance issue. However good or bad Ofwat and the EA have been, they answer to no-one, other than through the Secretary of State’s powers of appointment and the occasional parliamentary enquiry. Addressing the democratic deficit – perhaps by creating board posts for local authorities or expanding the role of the regional flood and coastal committees (already based around elected councillor membership), has huge advantages for a sector struggling with reputation and legitimacy. Both boards, if they are to remain, also need a wider membership base. (The same applies also to water company boards: the independent non-executive director appointment process is opaque in the extreme and hasn’t produced consistent internal challenge.)

 The Cunliffe review is a rare opportunity to transform water regulation: if we fail to grasp this opportunity we may regret it for a generation.   

Cunliffe Review Expert viewpoints

Want to find out how we can help your organisation?

Get in touch

Search our publications