Immediate Action Needed: Sustainability First Urges Swift Reform in the Water Sector Following Cunliffe Interim Report
June 3 2025 – Sustainability First is excited to welcome the Cunliffe Interim Report on the future of the UK water sector. This report marks a significant and encouraging step forward. However, we urge the government and regulators to act now and not wait until new legislation—expected to become law no sooner than 2028—or the next water price review process in 2029.
Our recent legal and policy briefing paper, supported by law firm Slaughter and May as part of our Fair for The Future initiative, highlights the substantial scope for urgent and meaningful action under current powers, if there is sufficient political will.
“The Interim Report rightly identifies the need for change, but the pace of reform must accelerate,” said Martin Hurst, Associate at Sustainability First. “We can and must act now — waiting another four years would be a profound disservice to the public and the environment.”
Immediate Opportunities for Action:
Sustainability First’s response identifies five key areas where regulators and government can lead immediate change:
- Smarter Regulation Through Data & AI
Ofwat and the Environment Agency (EA) already have the powers to incentives and/or require better data collection and invest in machine learning to modernise the industry and their regulatory approaches. - Nature-Based Solutions Over Carbon-Intensive Infrastructure
Current frameworks already allow for a faster shift from carbon-heavy concrete and chemical-based responses to nature-based approaches that deliver both carbon reductions and local flood risk benefits. The charity expresses concern that the Interim Report is largely silent on the sector’s carbon footprint. - Outcome-Based Regulation
There is no need to wait to begin shifting from process-heavy compliance models to a more outcome-oriented regulatory approach that rewards innovation and long-term value for communities and nature. - Strengthening Regional Governance
Existing bodies—such as the regional water resource groups and regional flood and coastal committees—can be empowered now to provide the ‘missing middle’ in water governance. Local authorities and mayors should have a stronger voice in decisions affecting their regions. Many decisions to support more vulnerable customers and communities could be devolved. - Empowering Customers and Challenging Culture
Ofwat should mandate and strengthen expert customer challenge groups within water companies, giving them a broader remit to question company culture and behaviour, not just engagement or service levels, to strengthen the public interest voice in water.
A Call to Overcome Regulatory Paralysis
Sustainability First endorses the Cunliffe Report’s diagnosis of a culture of regulatory risk aversion, particularly within the Environment Agency. The charity urges the government and regulators to adopt a more flexible, dynamic approach to regulation—starting immediately.
“We don’t need to wait for legislation to unlock change. The tools are already there—what’s needed is leadership, coordination, and confidence in the system’s ability to adapt,” said David Murray, Sustainability First’s Executive Director.
Blog