Your browser is out of date. Some of the content on this site will not work properly as a result.
Upgrade your browser for a faster, better, and safer web experience.

water report cunliffe review

Cunliffe Review: Act before the Act

Published in The UK Water Report. 

A lot has been written about the interim report from the Cunliffe review and the preceding call for evidence. Indeed, if the analysis of the huge number of responses to the call for evidence is correct, even more has been written by practically every water stakeholder in the country!

It is not the purpose of this article to reiterate or paraphrase this material. What’s worth reminding ourselves of, however, is Cunliffe’s remit, which spans the period beyond 2029. That is an important reason why his interim report talks a lot about the need for legislation (to be precise, primary legislation: a new Water Bill). It is worth reminding readers that – except in emergencies – options for new primary legislation must bid for a space in the next King’s Speech, which is not due for a year. And even if successful, any legislation on water will then have to compete with other Bills for time in front of the Commons and Lords – so is most unlikely to become law until well into 2027 at the very earliest. (Defra could and should pre-empt this by publishing a ‘draft bill’, for what is called pre-legislative scrutiny or a White Paper – but even then, it would change the timetable by only a few months).

And then much of the detailed enactment will require further secondary legislation and/or other changes. Anything going through this route is unlikely to have any real effect before PR29 (if indeed there is a PR29!) and even then, it may be too late fully to influence methodology statements and business plans.

Too long to wait
The view of many of us is that things cannot wait that long. Another four years of media about sewer overflows, and process regulation, means that trust in the sector (a major concern of Cunliffe) is unlikely to recover meaningfully. Another four years of £5bn a year spent on concrete and chemicals rather than nature will heavily increase the industry’s carbon footprint, will do little to change the underlying environmental quality of our rivers and seas and will miss a huge opportunity to reduce flood risk and create momentum to the catchment approach we so desperately need. Another four years of yesterday’s technology will fail to grasp the huge opportunities of machine learning/big data.

So, we need change before then – and ministers will not, we hope, have failed to notice that there is an election in 2029, and the attractiveness of some real change before then. Sustainability First’s work with legal firm Slaughter and May found that while legislation undoubtedly has its part, a lot can change without it: the prime requirement is political will and political cover for the regulators. This is particularly true for Ofwat, but there is also much the Environment Agency (EA) can do in terms of reducing its excessive risk aversion and looking for approaches to enable rather than prescribe.

So, what can we do?
The prime move, as mentioned above, must be political cover. The Cunliffe report provides a useful springboard. The secretary of state should act as soon as it is published, clearly signalling to Ofwat and the EA that the direction of travel must align with Cunliffe’s recommendations and also cover areas where Cunliffe hasn’t to date said much. This could be formalised through an updated Strategic Policy Statement (SPS) to Ofwat — and, ideally, something equivalent for the EA – which also cover trade-offs, rather than acting as a glorified, unbudgeted shopping list, which is what the last SPS was. He can also appoint a new chair of the EA and new board members of Ofwat – people who will drive this agenda.

In terms of particular changes, we have identified six areas where regulators and government can
lead immediate change:

1. Smarter regulation including through data and AI
Ofwat and the EA already have the powers to incentivise and/ or require better data collection and invest in machine learning to modernise the industry and their regulatory approaches. Our work a few years ago suggested that a combination of inflexible regulatory process (five-year price reviews, Water Resource Management Plans –WRMPs, Water Industry National Environment Programme – WINEP etc) and an excessive burden of proof mean that utility regulation across the piece can currently lag technological change by up to eight years. Ofwat and the EA should also work to align the details and processes of environmental and economic regulation where that makes sense e.g. delivery of WINEP, environmental performance. The two regulators should also look at the role for citizen science and innovative big data to inform real time performance monitoring.

2. Nature-based solutions
Current frameworks already allow for a faster shift than is currently allowed by the EA from carbonheavy concrete and chemicalbased responses to nature-based approaches that deliver both carbon reductions and local flood risk benefits. While it is disappointing that the Cunliffe Interim Report is largely silent on the sector’s carbon footprint – which our analysis suggests is set to increase very markedly following the WINEP and wider enhancement spend in PR24 – at a time when the government is missing its own carbon targets, there is much more that could be done.

Even more importantly, if we do not establish a growing profile of nature based spend over next few years we will risk starting the next five years in the same position as before, without the supply chain and partners to achieve a step change. Note that while Ofwat and the EA point to £3bn of ‘nature based’ spend in PR24, nearly all of this is hybrid solutions involving sustainable drainage. This is good, but the same switch is needed on nature approaches such as constructed wetlands.

3. Outcome-based regulation
There is no need to wait to begin shifting from process-heavy compliance models to a more outcome-oriented regulatory approach that rewards innovation and long-term value for communities and nature. Furthermore, the more emphasis which is put by the EA in particular on ever more detail on sewer discharges, the less impetus there will be on agriculture and other more substantial causes of poor environmental quality. As part of outcome-based approaches, we argue that the welcome reduction in bureaucracy for natural flood management and surface water flood reduction in the recent Government flood funding consultation needs to be matched by a similar approach on waste water – and that the WINEP and floods parts of the EA therefore need to work much more closely together, and to align their decision processes.

4. Strengthening regional governance
Existing bodies such as the regional water resource groups and regional flood and coastal committees can be empowered now to provide the ‘missing middle’ in water governance. Local authorities and mayors should have a stronger voice in decisions affecting their regions. Many decisions to support more vulnerable customers and communities could be devolved immediately. Ofwat should begin to explore innovative ways of working with regional bodies in the build-up to the next price review so that technical economic regulation can work to empower and support the regional voice rather than overriding it. Our recent briefing paper, as part of our response to the Cunliffe call for evidence, also argued that we will probably need a ‘variable geometry’ approach to regional water governance: supra regional for water resources (e.g. WRSE) and sub regional for wastewater (e.g. through the regional flood and coastal committees. This further strengthens the case for splitting water company licences between wastewater and water resources, something we think Ofwat probably has the power to do now if it wanted.

5. Empowering customers and challenging culture
Ofwat should mandate and strengthen expert customer challenge groups within water companies, giving them a broader remit to question company culture and behaviour, not just engagement or service levels, to strengthen the public interest voice in water. Both Ofwat and the EA could do much more to explain issues and their approach in terms that customers and citizens can hope to understand. There could also be a useful debate on the role of customer groups with regard to issues such as bonuses, dividends and wider financeability.

6. Working to place water investment in the wider context
The water industry is set to put in place £100-150bn of capital investment over the next five years. This is set against £200bn of energy spend (transmission and distribution upgrades, new nuclear, wind etc), an aspiration for 1.5m new homes, increased public sector capital spend on prisons, defence, schools, hospitals, transport, flood defences and a major drive for new data centres. Water requirements cannot sit in a vacuum: indeed, if this were to happen there would be a major risk of systemic under-delivery and cost inflation. Working with the new National Infrastructure and Service Transformation Authority, Defra, Ofwat, the industry and the EA need to form an ongoing view of risks to delivery and if there are constraints, which projects are ‘must haves’ and which are ‘nice to haves’.

Other readers will have their own list: I haven’t even mentioned the case for overhauling approaches to capital maintenance; a much more joined up approach to the long term (do we really need WRMPs, Drainage and Wastewater Management Plans, Long Term Delivery Strategies and River Basin Management Plans, all with their own methodologies?); the situation at Thames and minimising sector contagion; or the case for much better join up with digital and energy colleagues on adaptation risk – most of which I have written about in the past and none of which really require legislation!

Overarching all of this is the Cunliffe Report’s diagnosis of a culture of regulatory risk aversion, particularly within the EA. There is so much the government and regulators can do immediately to create a more flexible, dynamic approach to regulation. This is predominantly a cultural and political issue, not a legislative one.

Cunliffe Review Blog Expert viewpoints

Want to find out how we can help your organisation?

Get in touch

Search our publications