Your browser is out of date. Some of the content on this site will not work properly as a result.
Upgrade your browser for a faster, better, and safer web experience.

Ofgem Draft Determinations for RIIO-3 – Consultation Response Gas Distribution / Gas Transmission

Read the full response here.

Dear Ofgem

Sustainability First is a charity and think tank focused on social and environmental issues in the energy and water sectors with a record of engagement on policy and regulatory issues, including as past members of Ofgem’s RIIO-2 Challenge Group.

Recent work by Sustainability First on the future of the GB gas distribution networks includes our 2023 paper “Looking Through the FOG – the Future of Gas Networks”, our response to Ofgem on the Call for Evidence on the GD3 Business Plans (our “Response”), our submission to Ofgem on gas network disconnections and a day-long Sustainability First roundtable held on 1 May 2025. Sustainability First remains committed to a continuing role in taking forward this conversation.

As part of our response to Draft Determinations, we have prepared the attached Commentary which looks at the consumer and environment issues for gas distribution, in particular those relating to our work on the Future of Gas. In the Annex we also respond to specific questions raised by Ofgem, including some on gas transmission.

We support Ofgem’s continuing pressure on cost efficiency, given the current affordability challenge. Against the uncertain outlook for gas distribution, we support Ofgem’s use of uncertainty mechanisms. We agree with Ofgem’s modest move to accelerate depreciation for new gas distribution assets with the aim of obtaining a fair balance for future consumers. We see the overall increase in estimated network charges for GD3 as reasonable, including the impact of accelerated depreciation. We welcome the increased VCMA allowances to help support consumers in vulnerable situations.

However, we see some important gaps for Ofgem to address for Final Determinations. The overall positioning of the GD3 price control needs to be more future-facing with a clearer over-arching narrative. In particular:

We are concerned that in painting GD3 largely as ‘business-as-usual’, Ofgem risks selling the future short. For Final Determinations, Ofgem must ensure that the GD3 price control is based on a strategic narrative which is far more future-facing. The gas distribution networks must be actively supported by Ofgem in GD3 to start to prepare for the many complex demands implied by the net zero transition, including around heat decarbonisation. A clear articulation is needed of the priority areas for innovation and how these are being addressed.

Essential to this more future-facing narrative for GD3 should be an explicit focus on the imperative to reduce methane emissions. This is an element of the regulatory framework that has been unwound over successive price controls at a time when the international community is prioritising action in this area. While there are synergies with the safety driven repex work, it is vital for the environmental benefits of methane reduction in gas distribution to be explicitly considered and valued.

On safety, we see a pressing need for strategic engagement between the HSE, Ofgem and government. Detailed interpretation of HSE rules indirectly determines the amount of gas network spend yet substantive questions remain unanswered, creating needless funding uncertainty for the networks and risking customers over-paying e.g. on legacy disconnections, on leakage detection, on MOBs and on long-run operational costs. Urgent discussions are needed to clarify HSE requirements relating to GD3. This should then be followed by a longer-term strategic dialogue on how best to manage safety cost-effectively in the context of a network with declining customer numbers.

Finally, early in the GD3 price control period, work is needed to fill policy gaps that are crucial for GD4 planning. This includes the welcome work heralded by DESNZ to look at the longer-term regulatory framework and an acceleration of the work Ofgem has initiated on customer disconnections. Ofgem should set out the work needed in this GD3 “window” including any additional GD3 requirements for the networks to prepare or provide evidence.

We would also highlight the following specific “asks” for GD3 Final Determinations:

  • Vulnerability – the introduction of a licence obligation to ensure that companies deliver their “business as usual” vulnerability work which is now being funded through baseline;
  • RESP coordination – provision of baseline funding for RESP engagement, reflecting the new Ofgem licence condition and recognising the importance of GDN data to the RESPs;
  • Net zero (NZARD) – an increase in the NZARD cap (capped at GD2 levels updated for inflation) to accommodate the range of new activities it is expected to cover, including innovative approaches to methane leakage and RESP co-ordination;
  • Consumer satisfaction – a re-weighting of the CSAT incentive to reflect the declining importance of connections; and
  • Environmental Action Plans – close monitoring by Ofgem of key elements of company EAPs (in particular, methane emissions and biomethane injections) rather than simply relying on stakeholders to hold companies to account via the Ofgem “reputational incentive”.

On gas transmission we welcome the strong focus on reducing methane emissions – albeit we raise questions around the level of ambition in some of the targets. We are struck by the contrast with gas distribution which lacks this focus on reducing methane emissions despite significantly higher emission levels. We would urge Ofgem to adopt a more consistent approach across gas transmission and distribution on methane reduction and to encourage the sharing of learning.

Read the full response here.

Future of Gas OFGEM RIIO3 Consultation Submissions

Want to find out how we can help your organisation?

Get in touch

Search our publications