Your browser is out of date. Some of the content on this site will not work properly as a result.
Upgrade your browser for a faster, better, and safer web experience.

If you’re in a hole…: Views on using strategic communications to help restore trust.

Published in The UK Water Report. Written by Martin Hurst – Sustainability First Associate

A recent Indepen Forum had an interesting discussion about the public positioning of companies in ‘turnaround’. The discussion being under the Chatham House Rule, I can’t reveal what individuals said. But it set attendees thinking about how the water industry, and specific companies, should manage their communications.

For better or worse, while some people are starting to see Thames as a special case, the industry as a whole (or at least its owners) is still viewed by many as untrustworthy, venal and responsible for most of the pollution in our rivers. I know that much of this is historic, and that many great things are now being done. I also accept the differentiation between companies. But while a few companies have started to change local viewpoints (Portsmouth Water may be an example here), to some extent the industry is still lumped together in the public mind. This may well feel (and be) unfair. But the industry has for some time been a political football and (to mix my sporting metaphors) politicians didn’t get where they are by backing horses perceived as losers. Equally under-fire regulators will try and deflect blame. And there will inevitably be future bad news – poor EPA scores, further droughts etc. In what follows I cast myself as a critical friend of the industry (and of the regulators). But I would like to be a little controversial: let me know what you think.

Three prescriptions
Three prescriptions for companies in this position came over consistently at the Indepen Forum.

First, don’t be afraid to say sorry – and to keep saying sorry. I think the industry did this through Water UK initially. But the turnaround companies stressed the need for apologies to run as a core part of the message for perhaps three or more years in order to stick. The water industry needs to say this more often and for longer. The Dale Carnegie mantra ‘say it once, say it a hundred times’ is still relevant.

Second, under-promise and over-deliver. Taking a step back from proactive comms and really getting one’s house in order is crucial to re-establishing trust. And once a company trying to recover
trust says/promises something which is wrong or isn’t delivered, this can set them back a year at least.

Third, put yourself out there and listen, however painful this may feel! It is one of the roles of leadership to take a hit for the company and to be there to be shot at. Again, saying sorry in public can really help.

Six more

I would endorse all of these points with six additional ones:

  • Keep a tight grip on your PR/public affairs teams – the former in particular are used to ‘selling the company’ which inevitably can mean over selling. There needs to be a very clear core script, with relatively little scope for variation/initiative.
  • Be careful before you try and deflect blame to other firms in the sector. In my experience this rarely works, rather it simply gives the impression of ‘cats fighting in a bag’.
  • Work very hard to combat factual inaccuracies on social media. In the current febrile environment, things can go viral within a couple of hours. The best government  departments have established teams to monitor social media in real time – including out of office hours – and to issue strictly factual corrections. This can often halt a potential story in its tracks.
  • Concentrate on local media above national. National media usually (the Times/BBC might be an exception) have a critical ‘house line’ on an issue like water, and even if they don’t, journalists will look for an ‘angle’ to hang an article on (typically a negative angle, good news doesn’t sell). By contrast, local journalists are often simply grateful for material. This was something I learnt from some of the very best comms people in the trade.
  • Work overtime to keep your local MPs and local authority leaders and cabinet members in touch. Perhaps get your local MP to cut the ribbon on a new piece of kit – there’ll be lots of those over the next five years. Whatever happens do not do what happened with Severn Trent in the major 2007 water outage, which was to allow a crisis/pressure of work to get in the way of answering communication from MPs.
  • Finally, wherever possible coinvent messaging and substance with your stakeholders – willing third-party endorsement is the absolute holy grail here. This does mean ceding some control.

(There is a separate issue about the role of Water UK, but despite membership clamour for the trade body to accentuate the positive, I think most of the above recommendations apply to them too – though they may be best placed to front up in national fora such as the Today programme and, see above, continue to offer the collective ‘sorry’.)

Counter-cultural
What didn’t come up in the Forum is quite how difficult it is for senior players to do all of this. I found myself in Number 10 as a senior policy advisor for Tony Blair’s second term. By that time there was a realisation that the perception of excessive ‘spin’ could be counterproductive. But that realisation didn’t seem to connect with the gut reaction to put the maximum positive stance on every issue. I know that’s partly the nature of politics ( a week is a long time etc.). But I think it goes deeper. The leadership of a company has to authentically espouse changes and celebrate success to motivate their own staff. It is very hard to do this while keeping their own sense of perspective and maintaining discipline about public messaging.

This may be even more true when the regulatory system is pouring petrol on the fire (see my previous article on the misguided EPA system), and when investors are looking for quick reputational change. So, this isn’t easy, I accept that parts of the industry are ahead of the game, and it’s counter-cultural for both CEOs and public affairs departments. But a more strategic approach to comms is really important: we all need to play a slightly long game to restore reputation.

Listen to a breakdown of this issue with our Executive Director, David Murray, and our Chair of the Board, John Lunn.

Water Expert viewpoints

Want to find out how we can help your organisation?

Get in touch

Search our publications