Your browser is out of date. Some of the content on this site will not work properly as a result.
Upgrade your browser for a faster, better, and safer web experience.

The Cunliffe Review: A Watershed Moment for the UK’s Water Sector

(This article was first published in The Water Report)

The UK water sector could be on the brink of its most significant transformation since privatisation, thanks to the Cunliffe Review. Launched by the government in October 2024, this comprehensive review aims to address the myriad challenges facing the sector, from environmental sustainability to regulatory reform. As we delve into the implications of this review, it is essential to understand the context and the potential impact on – and opportunities for – the future of water management in the UK.

Sir Jon Cunliffe’s Review – commissioned by Steve Reed, the Secretary of State for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs – aims to overhaul the UK’s water sector to ensure it meets the demands of the 21st century. Its primary objectives include improving water quality, enhancing environmental sustainability, and ensuring the sector’s financial resilience. This initiative comes at a critical time, as the UK grapples with the dual challenges of climate change and increasing demand for water resources.

From Concrete to Nature – Environmental Sustainability

One of the central themes of the Cunliffe Review is environmental sustainability. The review recognises that the current approach to water management is inadequate in addressing the environmental challenges we face.

Our rivers and seas face systemic risks that demand immediate action. We must shift from relying on concrete-heavy, chemical-intensive approaches to working with nature. This means giving regulators the flexibility to foster collaboration and building a strong nature supply chain over the next five years. Only by uniting water companies, local stakeholders, and regulators can we achieve sustainable, cost-effective improvements to water quality. We need to see a much more joined up approach to the long term planning of water management, including asset maintenance and the supply chains needed to meet these needs.

As highlighted in (Sustainability First associate) David Elliott’s thinking shared at the recent CIWEM Freshwater Futures Conference, the current governance model often misaligns efforts to restore river health with the pressures affecting it. The focus on grey infrastructure solutions has limited the effectiveness of interventions, often leading to inadequate and unsatisfactory outcomes for river health.

“The current system of siloed regulations stifles progress. We need a more holistic approach that balances regulatory requirements with outcome-driven strategies for healthier rivers and oceans.” David Elliott, Associate, Sustainability First.

Elliott’s talk underscored the need for a more holistic approach to catchment governance. By realigning efforts with the pressures and those best able to affect them, the review aims to enable an optimal river restoration programme through a wider range of interventions. This includes embracing nature-based solutions (NBS) and community-based approaches to enhance river catchment resilience.

Regulatory Reform

The review also addresses the need for regulatory reform. The current regulatory framework is often siloed and incomplete, limiting the range of financeable solutions. As Martin Hurst pointed out in his recent talk at the pre-Christmas CIWEM Freshwater Futures Conference presentation, the disproportionate regulatory structures have led to an excessive burden of proof for new approaches, stifling innovation and progress.

“The water industry needs to be held to account on how it manages its assets, but it also needs to be freed up by regulators to work more closely with farmers, the third sector and local authorities to reduce pollution and restore rivers, rather than relying solely on treatment and chemicals. Such nature-based solutions are more eco-friendly, cost-effective, low-carbon, and help mitigate flooding.” Martin Hurst, Associate, Sustainability First.

Hurst advocates for a shift towards outcome-based regulation, allowing water companies and other stakeholders to achieve better water quality in the most cost-effective way. This involves working with farmers and land managers to reduce pollution and restore rivers, rather than relying solely on treatment and chemicals. Cunliffe’s review aims to create a more flexible regulatory environment that encourages innovation and collaboration.

Financial Resilience

Financial resilience is another critical focus of the Cunliffe Review. The review recognises that the water sector must be financially robust to meet future challenges. This includes ensuring that investments are directed towards sustainable and cost-effective solutions. The review also highlights the importance of involving local stakeholders in decision-making processes to ensure that investments align with community needs and priorities.

Nature-Based Solutions: A Path Forward

One of the most promising aspects of the Cunliffe Review is its emphasis on nature-based solutions (NBS). As highlighted in both presentations, NBS offer a more sustainable and cost-effective approach to water management. These solutions include sustainable drainage systems, constructed wetlands, and partnerships between water companies and land managers. NBS not only improve water quality but also provide additional benefits such as flood protection, carbon sequestration, and enhanced biodiversity. By integrating NBS into the water management framework, the review aims to create a more resilient and sustainable water sector.

Pragmatically, a hierarchical approach to where and when NBS might be most appropriate as a solution, could be adopted: First look at input reduction – fewer chemicals, fertiliser, microplastics. Then look at nature based approaches, and then consider hybrid approaches which may include grey infrastructure and chemical treatments. Only then – once all of the above options have been considered, should we look to concrete/chemical treatment on their own. At the moment an inversion of this hierarchical approach seems to be the norm.
Governance with community engagement for public trust at its heart.

The Cunliffe Review also emphasises the importance of community engagement and public trust. Building public trust is essential for the success of any regulatory reform. The review advocates for greater transparency and accountability in decision-making processes. This includes involving local communities in the development and implementation of water management plans.

By fostering a sense of ownership and responsibility among stakeholders, Sustainability First hopes for this review to highlight the need for a more inclusive and participatory approach to water management. This is particularly important in addressing the social and economic dimensions of water management, ensuring that the benefits of sustainable practices are shared equitably. This could fall under the wider umbrella of water companies being required to have a public purpose responsibility.

Sustainability First proposes a radical rethink of catchment governance, aligning efforts with the actual pressures on water systems and empowering those best placed to address them.

Key recommendations include:

  1. Integrated Management: Addressing land use, infrastructure, pollution, and societal behaviours to create a comprehensive plan.
  2. Collaborative Partnerships: Optimizing co-investment between public and private entities to address both environmental and social challenges.
  3. Empowered Catchment Plans: Establishing authoritative plans with clear governance structures and a systems-based hierarchy.
  4. Adaptive Governance: Embracing risk-based, flexible approaches to reflect the complexities of natural systems while ensuring plans remain financeable.

This urgent shift requires bold leadership and a shared commitment to protecting our water environments for future generations. Sustainability First invites policymakers, industry leaders, and communities to explore its proposals and join the call for change.

Conclusion

Could Cunliffe be the turning of the tide for the UK’s water sector, putting environmental and societal good at its heart? A call for evidence is planned for the new year, with the aim to conclude the review by June, allowing time to prepare any necessary legislation or guidance before PR29 gets underway. Addressing the key challenges of environmental sustainability, regulatory reform, financial resilience, and collaborative engagement, Sir Jon’s review is seeking to create a more robust and sustainable water management framework. Its emphasis on seeking out nature-based solutions and effective community engagement ideas, further underscores the review’s commitment to a holistic and inclusive approach.

As the review progresses, it will be crucial for all stakeholders to collaborate and contribute to this transformative process. The future of the UK’s water sector depends on our collective ability to embrace innovation, sustainability, and inclusivity. The Cunliffe Review provides a unique opportunity to reshape the sector for the better, ensuring that it meets the needs of both current and future generations.

Cunliffe Review Water Blog

Want to find out how we can help your organisation?

Get in touch

Search our publications