Your browser is out of date. Some of the content on this site will not work properly as a result.
Upgrade your browser for a faster, better, and safer web experience.

DNOs’ future role in supporting the rollout of low carbon technologies

We have worked on the issues around RIIO price controls over many years with several major Sustainability First projects examining particular aspects. We have also served as members of the earlier government / Ofgem Smart Grids Forum, Ofgem’s Strategic Advisory Board for market-wide half-hourly settlement and Ofgem’s RIIO-2 Challenge Group. We provided a full response to the ED3 Framework Consultation and a short response to the SSMC.

In this letter we offer some broad reflections on what Ofgem is proposing. We also attach short answers to some of the questions.

Support for pilots
We have previously encouraged Ofgem to look at all of the work that has been undertaken to date in this area. This includes multiple DNO projects on energy efficiency funded via the Network Innovation Allowance and also the Strategic Innovation Fund. Sustainability First produced a comprehensive paper to Ofgem in March 2021 on ‘What is the DNO Role on Energy Efficiency?’.

Where new roles for DNOs are considered, the best approach is likely to be to trial alternative approaches to the new role in limited areas, before deciding which, if any to roll out on a national scale. We had made a clear proposal in 2021, sadly not pursued, for a beacon innovation project of just this kind on energy efficiency, to enable a clearer view on next steps for the start of ED3. Given our previous proposal, we are pleased that in its consultation Ofgem acknowledges the benefit of carrying out pilots in relation to any potential Expanded Role in this space. Such an approach to addressing the evolving role of DNOs would likely lead to far superior outcomes to spending time and resources trying to figure out the best model in theory and then launching it everywhere in one go.

However, Ofgem then also needs a way of ensuring that successful innovations are rolled out as BAU across all networks. This is an ongoing theme in the innovation space which Ofgem is seeking to address through a more programmatic approach. In the consultation Ofgem flags a number of recent innovation projects (such as the E.ON / NPG EmpowerFlex partnership). Ofgem needs to reflect on how projects like this could be rolled out more widely if they are seen as successful.

Existing obligations
We continue to remind Ofgem that DNOs do have an existing licence obligation in this area. Condition 31 E.1 refers to ‘promoting the uptake of measures to improve energy efficiency where such services cost-effectively alleviate the need to upgrade or replace electricity capacity and support the efficient and secure operation of the distribution system. This may include procuring energy efficiency services, where it is economic and efficient to do so’. In our view this existing role needs to be given more prominence and already provides clear guidance on where DNOs should be funding measures (ie limited to where it is cost effective for them to do so, as is the case with flexibility).

We also noted previously that energy efficiency plays an important role in enabling flexibility with electric heat. Absent a separate thermal store (which adds costs and takes up space) consumers will be dependent on the thermal mass of their properties to use heat flexibly (by pre-heating their home). The consultation mentions the benefits of energy efficiency in terms of overall demand reduction and peak shaving but not broader flexibility benefits. With a growing reliance on flexibility (for DSOs and the system at large) this “enabling” aspect of improved energy efficiency needs greater recognition.

Crucially, as we flagged in our 2021 paper, for DNOs to make cost effective use of energy efficiency there needs to be an agreed common evaluation methodology so that the costs and benefits in avoided /  deferred network investment are assessed on a standard basis across DNOs.

Our view on the proposals
In terms of the roles set out in the consultation:

  • We see a strong case for DNOs playing an Enhanced Co-ordination Role based around improved data and collaboration with local authorities and community groups to help identify where energy eƯiciency and LCTs (solar and battery) could deliver the greatest societal benefit and make most sense from a network perspective. In our view this should also include DNOs making a contribution to funding of LCTs / energy efficiency where it would reduce DNO costs (in line with SLC 31E). Given our work on the Future of Gas, we were pleased to see reference to collaboration with gas networks as a potential part of this role.
  • We are less convinced at this stage that there is a case for giving the DNOs an Expanded Role. Socialising these costs through the RAV and ultimately the energy bill is a regressive form of funding. In our view funding for these measures for those unable to pay should ideally come through taxation. We do recognise the benefits of an area based approach but would hope that could be facilitated through improved coordination, including through the RESPs. That said, given the scale of the challenge, we see merit in pilots to explore any opportunity areas identified through this consultation. In particular we would be keen for any pilots to be centred in particular on lower income households and those at risk of fuel poverty.

We hope you find our comments helpful and would be happy to discuss further.

Yours faithfully
Judith Ward, Associate
Maxine Frerk, Associate

Fair for the Future Future of Gas OFGEM Consultation Submissions

Want to find out how we can help your organisation?

Get in touch

Search our publications