Your browser is out of date. Some of the content on this site will not work properly as a result.
Upgrade your browser for a faster, better, and safer web experience.

A Fairer Deal for Communities: Why It’s Time to Make Community Benefits Mandatory

As the UK accelerates its shift to net zero, new energy infrastructure will become increasingly visible in our landscapes—and in our lives. From wind farms to transmission lines, these projects will touch communities up and down the country. That’s why Sustainability First strongly supports the introduction of a mandatory framework for community benefits.

Our recent response to the Department for Energy Security and Net Zero’s (DESNZ) consultation makes the case clearly: relying on a voluntary system isn’t good enough. Too many communities have seen inconsistent support. A postcode lottery on public benefit risks eroding trust—and fairness—in the transition. We’ve learned through our Fair for the Future and Sustainable Futures projects that people need to see the public value in major infrastructure. Minimum standards, clearly communicated and fairly applied, can create a more level playing field. They can also provide confidence to both developers and communities, reducing friction and improving outcomes.

Proportionality and Flexibility Matter
That doesn’t mean heavy-handed rules. The best regulation focuses on outcomes, not tick-box exercises. A well-designed framework should be flexible enough to respect existing local arrangements that work, while offering consistency and clarity where capacity is limited. We support the idea of exploring a generation licence condition—regulated by Ofgem—as a practical enforcement route that avoids unnecessary bureaucracy.

Getting Governance Right
Where community governance is strong, it should be supported. But not all communities start from the same place. In areas without legal or administrative capacity, a well-defined Fund Administrator role can provide essential support—particularly for pooled funds or multi-site projects. Crucially, communities must still retain control over how funds are spent and prioritised. A menu of governance models, templates, and peer support could help provide consistency without stifling action.

Benefits Must Be Strategic, Not Symbolic
We back the decision not to prescribe what community benefit funds can be used for. However, we encourage DESNZ to frame examples with care. Quick wins like bill discounts are tempting—but investments in long-term resilience, inclusion, and skills can be transformational. Critically, benefit funds should be allowed to support core costs of local organisations. This kind of revenue support is often overlooked, but it’s what keeps the lights on—literally and figuratively—in the places that need it most.

Shared Ownership: Empowerment with the Right Tools
Shared ownership should be seen as complementary to community benefit payments, not a replacement. When done well, it creates longer-term income streams and embeds a genuine sense of ownership. But shared ownership also comes with legal and financial risks. Government support—through model legal agreements, risk-sharing tools, and technical advice—will be key if this is to be accessible to all communities, not just the well-resourced few.

The Role of Local and Regional Actors
We see real value in regional approaches—particularly where developments span multiple communities. The new Regional Energy Strategic Planners (RESPs) being developed by the NESO can help deliver more joined-up thinking. Local authorities also have a critical role to play, though their involvement should be enabling, not directive. Community benefit must remain community led.

Build Capacity. Sustain Engagement.
Capacity-building isn’t just about training. It’s about helping communities develop the confidence to lead, the ambition to shape their futures, and the resources to sustain relationships over the long term. Engagement with developers must go beyond planning consultations—relationships should be nurtured across the lifecycle of assets.

One example at East Lammermuir Community Council highlights what’s possible when communities are empowered and engaged. But many communities don’t have this starting point. Levelling the playing field means recognising these disparities—and resourcing communities accordingly. In fact, proactively engaging with communities where vulnerability is high and capacity is low, may offer a great opportunity to a just and fair transition to a greener economy, in practice.

Looking Ahead
We welcome the leadership DESNZ is showing on community co-ownership. Getting this framework right is essential—not just for fairness, but for trust. A just energy transition won’t happen by accident. It will take clear standards, honest collaboration, and sustained support.

At Sustainability First, we’ll continue to champion a fairer, more inclusive approach to infrastructure and energy governance. Later this year, we’ll publish findings from our public sounding board with communities directly affected by the Great Grid Upgrade, who live in communities hosting major infrastructure projects, and who could be recipients of community benefit funds, as well as prospective co-owners of energy generation schemes.

We look forward to feeding that into the next stage of policy development.

DESNZ Inclusive by Design Blog Expert viewpoints

Want to find out how we can help your organisation?

Get in touch

Search our publications