Gas Matters – Expert Viewpoint by Maxine Frerk and Judith Ward
Summary: Policy discussions around the energy transition tend to focus on electrification but Sustainability First is also concerned at the significant policy gap around the customer journey for gas disconnections, and urges publication of a delayed Ofgem report. The current gas disconnections process is fragmented, confusing, poorly explained and also potentially costly and unfair for some customers. We therefore stress the need for clearer information and stronger coordination between suppliers and gas distribution networks. The piece also highlights how Ofgem must bear down on current disconnection costs. Relating directly to this, there is also urgent need for closer strategic engagement with the HSE on what constitutes a safe disconnection. Innovation also has an important role in reducing current disconnection costs. There are also longer-term questions on who should pay for gas disconnections at scale – but this is for government to address. The article also flags the unexplored potential of a ‘Disconnection Lite’ model – where customers might commit to no longer using gas but leave their meters and pipework in place for a period, paving the way for more coordinated, locally-based and lower-cost disconnections and a better customer experience. Our focus on gas disconnections forms a part of Sustainability First’s substantial work over the past three years on the Future of GB Gas Distribution.
_______________________________________________________________________
Introduction
Discussion of customer issues in the energy transition has an almost exclusive focus on electrification. The far-reaching impacts for gas consumers and for the gas networks get little attention. Since our initial work on the Future of Gas (2023), Sustainability First has continued to press for far greater policy and regulatory focus on these very big topics. A successful transition hinges on getting gas matters right.
Decommissioning of some or all of the gas distribution networks is several decades away. But a first basic step today – and a major policy gap –is a clear gameplan for management of customer disconnections. Today’s totals are small (~ 20,000 in 2024), but responsibility splits across different parties. For customers the process doesn’t join-up, isn’t transparent or clear. A seemingly simple request to end one’s gas supply can turn out to be ridiculously complex. Namely, to remove the gas meter and cut-off the pipe safely at the right place (which may also mean digging a bit of garden, path or nearby roadway). Of course, safety is paramount and gas distributors and suppliers aim for strict compliance. But the companies operate within siloes and lack a full customer picture. If heat-electrification is ever to seriously scale, needless obstacles on gas disconnection need clearing and the confused customer journey clarified. This is not rocket science. GDNs and suppliers must coordinate better, including a more ‘can-do’ mind-set. Innovation needs momentum to reduce disconnection costs. More locally-based approaches to gas disconnections need exploring as a means to reduce long-run costs. Ofgem, DESNZ and the HSE each have a role and it’s high time they step-up.
In 2025 Ofgem issued a Call for Input and ran a workshop programme focused on what a long-run framework for gas disconnections might look like. A report was expected in June, but appears to be on hold. It’s not clear why. We’ve repeatedly (and loudly) urged Ofgem to start with the short-term consumer issues.
Disconnections today – an urgent need to explain the process
A part of the customer decision to install a heat pump also involves understanding how to set about a gas disconnection and the likely cost. Even savvy energy sector colleagues have found this a headache.
First, a customer must approach their supplier to remove their gas meter. The supplier may or may not make a charge and this charge may vary. Second, the GDN (gas distribution network) must ensure the household pipework is safe. For this there are two separate routes. The “voluntary” route (so-termed by Ofgem), where you approach your GDN to safely cut-off the pipe-work based on your timetable and for which they charge up to £2000. Or, the so-called “safety” route whereby after a 12 month ‘pause’ (to account for all eventualities..), the GDN visits to make the pipe-work safe. Via this “safety” route, costs of all pipe removals are recovered across all GDN customers and the disconnecting customer does not pay a charge. An easy choice for a customer who is aware of the options and not timetable driven. But the lack of information to help consumers navigate their way through is woeful.
Among the GDNs only one (WWU) properly explains the process via their website, noting that the voluntary route should be used if doing building work and need the job done in specific timescales. The three other GDNs simply invite you to apply for a paid-for “voluntary” disconnection. And among suppliers, only a couple provide information online, including indication of their own charges for meter removal (free with Octopus but £235 with E.ON).
Explaining the customer journey for a gas disconnection should have been a quick and easy fix. We offered our own thoughts on early steps to improve the customer journey in this Strawman (March 2026). Ofgem’s thinking was first for an investigation phase, with implementation later. But it shouldn’t have taken an extended investigation to ensure clearer basic consumer advice – and we’re still waiting. The Ofgem workshops have at least given a better sense of what in the near term is practical and Ofgem must now move quickly to address the information gaps for customers. Ofgem must also work with suppliers on their end of the process. This includes far more transparency on supplier costs and charges for meter removals. What exactly now prevents Ofgem – or indeed DESNZ – simply telling both GDNs and suppliers to plug this basic consumer information gap and make the position clear ?
Who should pay for gas disconnections – an intractable question
One initial distraction was Ofgem’s early wish to address the intractable question of who should pay for gas disconnections over the long-term. The economist’s line (and Ofgem’s initial position) was that the disconnecting customer should pay. But given small volumes at this point, introducing a new gas disconnection charge would simply be one more barrier to heat pump take-up. Ofgem rightly now recognise that these long-term funding issues are complex. For the interim, Ofgem now accept the reality of the safety route as the customer-norm with no charge for pipework removal (but still a supplier charge for meter removal). Ofgem was also toying with capping the cost of a “voluntary” disconnection, but met push-back. Over time, as disconnection volumes increase significantly, we agree it would be unfair to expect the declining pool of remaining gas customers to fund disconnections – in particular if these are more likely to be lower income and vulnerable customers. Ultimately this will be for DESNZ to address as part of its wider work programme on the future of gas and affordability.
Pressing down on disconnection costs today
And while the longer-term “who pays?” question sits more clearly with DESNZ, there remains a crucial role for Ofgem to bear down very hard on gas disconnection costs right now. At over £1000 per disconnection, we could in theory face total household disconnection costs amounting to billions. Bold ambition is therefore needed today from both Ofgem and government to bring down these costs as far and as fast as possible. Again, there are short and longer term actions.
In GD3 Ofgem have introduced a volume driver for safety disconnections which should shine more light on those costs. GDNs seem to have ended-up with a wide range of allowed costs per disconnection, the reasons for which are not transparent. At the very least on disconnection costs, Ofgem must drive some basic efficiency savings through the RIIO mechanisms
However some real uncertainty remains – potentially both retrospective and going forward – due to an evolving HSE requirement on disconnections (regardless of voluntary or safety) to ensure safety at a property. As we understand it, this may require disconnection at the main (typically in the roadway) even for polyethylene (PE) pipes which until now have been considered safe – and which could potentially entail removing all pipe-work back to the gas main. If HSE insist on this approach, the costs of a gas disconnection could increase by an astonishing 2- or 3-times. This is a strategic conversation to which Ofgem and DESNZ must be party. Realistically, GDNs may not have much incentive to resist any such change as Ofgem say the resulting costs will be covered through a reopener. Defining a ‘safe’ cut-off – and whether this must always be at the main – must be more transparent given the very significant customer cost implications, and to which HSE typically give little weight. Excavating the road is the major cost element in removing low-pressure gas pipes and it’s astounding that there’s presently no industry-wide consensus on what constitutes a safe cut-off. An independent technical view could help cut-through this needless paralysis.
Innovation, data-flows and better customer insight – reducing costs and improving the customer experience
For GD3 we argued that Ofgem should incentivise technical innovation that’s focused on new ways to disconnect safely and more cost effectively. There are some promising GDN innovation projects: for example, pipes being back-filled with foam, or a new ‘squeeze-off’ tool. But Ofgem must do more to drive this kind of innovation across GDNs, including via the SIF. Ofgem and GDNs must also liaise with HSE to remove any needless barriers to successful innovation becoming BAU.
Current data flows on gas disconnections also need improvement. Suppliers and GDNs should communicate more clearly via Xoserve on when a customer wishes to be permanently disconnected. Not least, this would give GDNs more scope to package local disconnection work together (as well as a better customer experience).
Ofgem must also obtain better customer insights on gas disconnections. We know that many more people install heat pumps than disconnect from gas. Is this because they still want to keep gas for cooking? Or do they want to keep the option of reverting to gas? Or are they simply put off by the costs and complexity of the disconnections process? The Ofgem workshops included much discussion around what good customer service looks like (in abstract) but the customer voice – and any evidence – was decidedly lacking.
As part of GD3 Ofgem has introduced a reputational incentive around customer satisfaction with the disconnection process (with scope for this to become a financial incentive in due course, as it is for other elements of customer satisfaction). This is helpful in getting networks to focus on what matters to customers in terms of customer service (rather than the regulator being prescriptive about the detail). But the GDNs are only responsible for a part of the customer journey. More work is needed to bring GDNs and suppliers together to coordinate and improve the end-to-end customer experience.
Improved management of gas disconnections today is a key step towards lowering the costs of disconnections at scale. With the Warm Homes Plan anticipating 450,000 heat pump installations p.a. by 2030 – and with an emphasis within that on vulnerable and low income households, Ofgem needs to be clear what short-term steps are needed to ensure that these customers are supported in their move away from gas and not just in what they are transitioning towards.
Exploring models for ‘Disconnection Lite’ – options to allow for local planning on gas disconnections
We need a better future view – for customers, GDNs and suppliers – of possible models for ‘Disconnection Lite’ . That is, where a customer commits to not using gas but the gas meter and pipes remain in place for a period. Such approaches would require significantly different thinking – but could open the door on GDNs substantially reducing disconnection costs through coordination and planning for pipe removals more locally, rather than responding in a wholly piecemeal way as now to individual customer disconnection requests. From a customer standpoint, leaving the gas meter and pipes in place while not using gas could make financial sense for a decade or more. Today’s “safety” disconnection costs amount to ten-times the cost of an annual gas standing charge (~ £115 p.a) – and for a “voluntary” disconnection far more.
So, would this in fact be a problem ? Or could this even be helpful ?
First off, clarity is needed on the safety aspects of different models for Disconnection Lite : once again we’re in HSE’s hands but, as already noted, an independent expert view could help inform thinking. On the standing charge, some kind of discount may be appropriate if a customer formally commits to zero gas use (but the wider debate on standing charges cannot be ignored).
Common sense suggests Disconnection Lite could pave the way for gas disconnections at street or even building level – with almost certainly better outcomes for both customers and costs. This all needs working through of course – not just by HSE and GDNs – but also by the RESPs (the NESO regional energy strategic planners) – and certainly before Ofgem’s GD4 planning starts in earnest. There are also relevant use-cases that should be progressed and will offer valuable lessons. For example, multi-occupancy buildings where expensive work is required to replace risers and there are only a few customers left on gas. Exploring Disconnection Lite further, may also be relevant medium-term to network optionality. For example, pending fuller evidence of the potential for hybrid heat-pumps to deliver avoided whole-system costs and / or emissions reduction from bio-methane.
We’re still far off decommissioning, but steps outlined here could lead to improved management of the gas disconnections process overall and are therefore helpful precursors.
Conclusion
We’ve set out our thoughts for the short-term on what Ofgem needs to cover in its disconnections report –a sharp focus on better customer information from both GDNs and suppliers and far more ambition to drive cost reductions. Regardless of whether the Ofgem report is published, these gas matters need leadership and for Ofgem, DESNZ and HSE to make progress.
Maxine Frerk
Judith Ward
Associates. Sustainability First
