Two Cheers for DEFRA: Martin Hurst’s inside on the White Paper
Published in The UK Water Report. Written by Martin Hurst – Sustainability First Associate
So, the White Paper is now published. I’m sure you’ve all read it, or at least the Water Report’s excellent summary published the day after, and it is not the job of this article to tell you what you already know. I have been asked to give my slightly wider impressions as a former water director in Defra (and the author of the last UK water strategy, published in 2007 or 2008).
Hip Hip Hooray
Overall, I think the White Paper is pretty good. Remember first that a White Paper sets out policy, it is not for consultation, so if there are areas where further work is needed on/opinions sought a White Paper is not the place for dogmatic pronouncements. In fact, by cleverly creating the device of a Transition Plan – where Defra are already reaching out to stakeholders – Defra have created what in the trade is known as a ‘White Paper with Green edges’, Green Papers being consultative. We’ve already seen the first follow up consultation, on sludge.
Second, there is also the (small p) political backdrop. The White Paper must demonstrate the Government understands all the issues that matter to stakeholders without making commitments it can’t meet or for which there is no Whitehall consensus. Hence there is good material showing that investor interests, the need for progress on agriculture and transport run off, the long-term needs of infrastructure, the growth agenda, customer issues etc are all accepted, without too many definitive commitments. There is also some welcome pragmatism, most notably on the risks of a ‘throw everything up in the air and see where it lands’ approach to regional structures and some much-improved language about carbon footprints.
The one area where there was never going to be room for showing acceptance of selected stakeholder views was on renationalisation. This was made clear before Cunliffe, although there is one intriguing bit of text around mutual and other models.
However, while one can argue about the balance (there should have been more on links with flood and land management policies for example) there is one area where there is practically nothing said: potential risks to the water environment from/treatment of forever chemicals/micro plastics. The only reference I can find to chemicals is as an input to water treatment and the only reference to plastics is on wet wipes. Even committing to a proper independent study would be better than this.
Third there is the (capital P) politics. Although the Water Special Measures Act and the Cunliffe review have started to defuse some of the heat around sewer overflows, executive bonuses etc, this backdrop remains. So there was always going to have to be a bit of visible industry bashing in the substance and comms around the White Paper.
The missing third cheer
So why only two cheers (apart from the one omission mentioned above)? Well, practically everything in the White Paper could have been published months earlier. Granted there was a new secretary of state. And anyone who has been at senior levels in Whitehall knows the frustrations of trying to secure space for announcements in the ‘Number 10 grid’: i.e. ensure that your announcement doesn’t get in the way of the ‘strategic’ (for which read tactical) Government comms approach from the politicos in the centre. But even so, the delay has created expectations which I think could probably never be met. There is also the question of bills. We all know bills will need to continue to rise sharply. There has however been some political temporising here which has tied the hands of the welcome promise of a move to a mixed 5/10/25 year planning horizon.
Third, perhaps inevitably in the interests of presenting a comprehensive picture and giving all the stakeholder interests a suitable airing, the White Paper has issues of trade-offs and relative priorities. I hope the promised tougher strategic policy statements will tackle this, but I am pessimistic. Finally, there remains a danger that the rapid transition to work on the forthcoming Water Bill, and the creation of the new regulator, will take attention away from less ‘sexy’ but equally important quicker measures. The whole may therefore become less than the sum of its parts.
Minimum Viable Proposition
To this end, SSWAN (a brilliant coalition of NGOs, water companies, land managers and the supply chain), with Sustainability First, have been working up the idea of a ‘minimum viable proposition’.
This is our term for the smallest consistent package of legislative and non-legislative changes which together could create sufficient change in the outcomes we are seeking: water outcomes such as the natural environment, resilient water resources, public health, customer service and costs; but also related non-water outcomes such as flood reduction, land management/ farming and economic development. There are some clear pegs in the White Paper – such as ‘controlled discretion’ and reform to WFD/urban wastewater treatment directive – but they don’t constitute an overarching view of what must be done as a system. We doubt they will deliver the shift from process to outcome regulation, and to flexibility and forward-looking rather than safe and backward-looking solutions, which is needed.
There’s some stuff already on the SSWAN website https://www.sswan.co.uk/ and they’ll will be putting more out on this shortly, so watch this space. Do also talk to me or their great new chair Niki Roach.
ofwat Water Expert viewpoints