Water Reform: Mapping the Gaps
Published in The UK Water Report. Written by Martin Hurst – Sustainability First Associate
With so much policy activity in water, Martin Hurst looks at what is at risk of falling between the cracks.
My word this water space is changing quickly. By the time you read this, Defra may well have launched its Strategic Policy Statements and directions to Ofwat and the Environment Agency (EA), perhaps alongside its water Transition Plan. Writing to avoid instant obsolescence is therefore more than the usual challenge, so I’ll try and confine myself to identifying some of the gaps many of us see in what’s happening.
Department deluged
It seems hard for Defra to avoid becoming more and more tied into the urgent need to kick off PR29, to get work on the new regulator going, to decide what to do on regional planning and to get ahead of the game with regard to the new Water Bill. The regulators are doing a laudable job in trying to keep their show on the road. But it’s almost inevitable that more of the burden of setting future direction will have
to fall to Defra. That, plus the ongoing flood of handling the ministerial correspondence, Parliamentary
Questions, ministerial briefings etc. would keep anyone occupied. At least local election ‘purdah’ may
give them a breathing space.
It’s also the case that even successful mergers involve a big dislocation. When setting up Natural England, we reckoned that success would be emerging from the complexities of terms and conditions, TUPE consultation, pay equalisation, estates decisions and a single IT system – not to mention establishing a different culture and vision in the new body – with added value after two years. Some things will fall through the gaps. We urgently need a ‘map’ from the White Paper topics to ongoing work. We can see a number of things where someone needs to do some new serious thinking.
Eight to watch
Most important to my mind is that someone needs to ensure we have a robust structure for the long term/ the interest of the next generation of bill payers and citizens. The five/ten/25 year split suggested by ministers seems sensible, but making this work is the big challenge. The suite of DWMP/regional water bodies/ RAPID/WRMP is inconsistent and inefficient and new regional bodies could add to this.
We also need an institutionalised voice for the long term in regulation. ❙ Second, the digital world is moving very rapidly. Regulation needs to incentivise development of machine learning and living digital twins and systems-wide optimisation of AI, not hold it back: research by Sustainability First shows that regulation tends to be about seven years behind technology.
Equally, the role which machine learning can play in regulation has been massively underestimated: there are huge and growing amounts of data out where which we are not using properly. We also urgently need an ‘AI observatory’ to map and share what is happening across the industry. Dan Corry’s review of Defra regulators was very persuasive here.
Third we need a much more flexible regulatory system. It’s not only technology which is moving quickly, it’s also supply chains and labour markets – themselves reflecting world events – not to mention the climate. The idea that we can start setting plans in stone between now and 2028 for the year 2034 seems preposterous.
Fourth the two big regulations – the Water Framework and Urban Waste water Treatment Directives – are being looked at, which in my view is essential. But work on the next price review and WINEP, plus day-to-day regulation, is still inevitably rooted in the existing language. Even if we get new legislation under the new bill, someone needs to think how to retrofit regulation practice and PR29 to accommodate them.
Fifth, there seems a major gap in analysis on the impacts of regulation on the sector’s carbon emissions. The White paper touched on this, and UKWIR has also helped, but we think the excessive focus on concrete solutions in PR24 and the last WINEP is massively adding to the sector’s emissions. For policy and regulation to act in ignorance of these (in some cases I’m afraid what looks like wilful ignorance) is not acceptable. Equally, we need ready reckoners for the ‘carbon fixing’ of the various types of nature-based solutions.
Sixth (I’ve nearly finished I promise), is how trade-offs should be drawn. I love the Cunliffe concept of constrained discretion, which I hope will also be accompanied by a rebalancing of regulatory ‘risk appetite’ towards less risk averse regulation. But someone needs to set out options for which trade-offs can properly be left to regulators, and which are essentially political decisions which need to be made by ministers. The SPS to Ofwat may include this, but past experience doesn’t lead me to be very hopeful.
Seventh, the new regulator could very easily exacerbate the ‘double jeopardy’ referred to in Cunliffe with the setting of what companies can and can’t spend money on alongside performance incentives and penalties, civil penalties and now criminal sanctions. We need to think about what lawyers call the ‘separation of powers’ and at a minimum a very strong internal Chinese wall.
Finally, it seems to me that there is a feeling that the new ombudsman has sorted ‘the customer issue’. While the proposals are progress, it hasn’t. The new regulator needs a clear objective to ensure inclusive high quality customer service for all and protections, not just for low income consumers, but also the millions in vulnerable situations during supply outages, heatwaves and floods. I work a lot in social housing where since Grenfell it has become abundantly clear that regulation needs to ensure the customer voice is heard consistently, and well beyond the handling of complaints. This to my mind is a non-negotiable component of supervisory regulation. Defra cannot afford to leave consumer and civil society voices behind if it is to genuinely build trust and confidence.
Don’t get me wrong, this is not knocking Defra, the EA or Ofwat. It’s simply that, given current pressures, it’s asking a huge amount of them to have the ‘controlling’ mind which sits above all the stuff which has to be done to impossibly tight deadlines. I hope the above helps, let me know your thoughts.
Martin Hurst – Sustainability First Associate
Contact SF: info@sustainabilityfirst.org.uk
Defra Environment Agency ofwat Water Expert viewpoints