What we need to hear from new infrastructure bodies
The case for investment in utilities infrastructure has been clear for many years – and finally these calls seem to have been heeded. However, there remain significant uncertainties over supply chain availability and investability of energy and water company plans. Martin Hurst, of UCL and Sustainability First writes for Utility Week about what government, regulators and new institutions need to do to address these challenges.
That the UK needs major spending on infrastructure is self-evident.
In the public sector, we need a large programme to expand our prisons, upgrade our schools and hospitals, and secure the transport we need for the next 50 years, following an extended period of deferred investment.
To facilitate this the Chancellor has announced a change to public finance rules which will free up extra spend and has suggesting merging local authority pension funds to provide the critical mass needed for strategic infrastructure finance.
In electricity, we have a massive energy decarbonisation challenge: increasing renewable energy and carbon capture, replacing ageing nuclear, increasing electricity supply (partly to enable decarbonisation of transport and heat but also things like data centres to support AI), and expanding transmission and distribution networks to support all of the above.
In gas we simply do not yet know, pending government decisions, how far investment will need to focus on decommissioning, and how far on recommissioning/repurposing existing infrastructure. Either way, spend will be in all probability required.
And the need for investment in the water sector has been well publicised, in particular to make water supply resilient to climate change and to address the backlog in cleaning up our wastewater system and our rivers and seas.
Finally, the new government has pledged to build 1.5 million new houses, which will both require new funding and also add to requirements from energy and water and to combat growing risk of flooding. A lack of funding in these areas could have knock on effects on deliverability of many projects in other sectors could be derailed.
At the same time, public spending is constrained. The UK’s attractiveness to international investment has fallen as a result of Brexit, the Truss mini budget and well-publicised default risk, most notably of Thames Water. And there are also constraints on the supply chain.
The government’s new National Infrastructure and Service Transformation Authority (NISTA), announced in October and set to be up and running in Spring 2025 has been sold as bringing strategy and delivery oversight of major infrastructure together across the country, which if it happens will be very welcome. The last thing we need is an uncoordinated bidding war for private finance and scarce supply chain resources. But it is unclear how many real teeth that body and the related task force of infrastructure investors will be given, and there is little indication of how that body, will work with the economic regulators/the National Energy System Operator (NESO) and private companies in utilities.
Utilities and their regulators also need to learn the lessons drawn out in the National Infrastructure Commission’s latest (October 24) report on the costs of infrastructure, which identifies four key problems across UK infrastructure: a lack of strategic direction; client and sponsorship challenges; a constrained supply chain; and inefficient consenting and compliance. Utility players reading this will no doubt recognise a number of these issues.
Options for utility sectors
The traditional model for investment in water and in energy networks has been that of the regulated utility, with the regulated asset base (RAB) and five-yearly price controls at the heart of decision making. Upstream energy production has, by contrast, for some time used and considered a wider variety of tools: contracts for difference (CfDs), offshore and now potentially onshore electricity transmission options.
One notable exception was the c£5 billion Thames Tideway Tunnel, which retained the RAB model, but through a separate licensed infrastructure project with independent finance and a guaranteed long-term future funding settlement from water bills. Most people accept that this has been a success. The model (the wider version of which is now referred to as SIPR – from the enabling Specified Infrastructure Project Regulations) is being considered for wider types of projects, including in transport and nuclear.
Another exception is the approach to interconnectors in electricity, where construction can be undertaken by anyone other than regulated entities at a measure of risk as freestanding projects, with income derived from future carrying charges, themselves subject to a cap and collar.
The water regulator Ofwat (and the Penrose review for the last administration) has recognised that better value could potentially be gained for customers though similar routes, given that traditional utility network companies are not always good at delivering and financing large projects. They are, after all, operational companies. Ofwat has therefore first moved towards ‘direct procurement for customer’ (DPC) models as a default scenario above a certain threshold and is now considering extending this, including using SIPR Thames Tideway type approaches for the new Fenland and Lincolnshire reservoirs. These are argued to be a credible way of introducing some competition into natural monopolies
Ofgem’s approach by contrast is more traditional, even with the £60 billion plus National Grid upgrades, although they have been willing to agree to longer-term settlements. This may reflect a combination of the size of the companies, a rather better track record, legitimate concerns about potential delay from novel financing/procurement approaches given the urgency of Grid upgrade, and less of a risk premium/ lower contagion from Thames Water’s problems than is present in water.
For water, however, Ofwat is on the right lines. There is a strong case for creating freestanding projects that are of wider interest to infrastructure investors who have become disillusioned with the traditional model, and which allow most companies to concentrate on the core job of managing increasingly creaking networks. Ofwat should, in fact, go further and consider requiring the bundling of some smaller projects into investible propositions, just as has happened in the past for other small-scale projects such as schools. For example, there is no clear case for 16 companies to have independent procurement exercises for smart water meters (or even necessarily to buy the meters at all, rather than procure the data from them).
The supply chain
It is no secret that the UK supply chain is creaking. The price of steel has rocketed yet again. Demand for construction labour has outstripped supply, with a post-Brexit exodus of the traditional foreign labour force and systematic underinvestment in domestic skills and Further Education. Global instability has also played its part. It is not poor management that is leading the Environment Agency to deliver only two-thirds of the pledged additional flood defence protection in the current six-year funding cycle, it is the constrained supply chain.
It is also becoming clear that simply allowing all the various sectors that need to expand infrastructure to compete for the same supply chain could lead to unnecessary cost inflation and an un-strategic mix of projects actually getting completed. What we need from the new NISTA (and the proposed new wider industrial strategy) is:
a) a strategic national portfolio of forward major infrastructure projects, with long-term funding pledges to encourage investment in skills etc.;
b) improved construction training and support for apprenticeships in this sector;
c) encouragement for foreign labour (not just in terms of visas, but also the mood music towards such labour) and foreign supply chain players – one advantage of some of the private finance type approaches is that they seem to have brought in foreign supply chain firms, but there is also the potential for wider and much needed innovation; and
d) some method of prioritisation and co-ordination other than first come, first served and a wider recognition of the relationship between sectors (e.g. we can’t build new houses without new energy transmission/distribution and water/sewage capacity/connections).
A few further considerations
The focus of the new NISTA appears to be on infrastructure over the next 10 years. We need to recognise that for utilities, and for water in particular given the challenge of resilience to climate change, that 10 years is probably too short a horizon: indeed, Ofwat have already required companies to produce 25-year long term delivery strategies.
These long-term strategies could be a gold mine in terms of setting out a future water infrastructure requirement. It could enable water to move quickly to an integrated national wastewater and water resources plan, of the sort overseen in energy by the NESO.
There is, of course a major problem in terms of long-term planning for gas infrastructure, in that the government has not yet decided what the long-term role of the gas network should be. There is an urgent need for certainty here: in part to enable gas utilities to access funding and supply chain where investment is needed (including in any decommissioning of stranded assets).
Ofwat in particular (and/or the various recently announced reviews led by Dan Corry and John Cunliffe) needs to look at the findings from the NIC report. If the industry is to ensure good quality and appropriate commissioning and contract management, Ofwat probably needs to evolve its approach as the number of direct procurement etc. projects grows. This could both ensure that its oversight is proportionate and strategic, but also to better prioritise and work through dependences between projects.
There is actually a question as to whether, as direct procurement type approaches become the norm, and we move from a few projects to a pipeline of 25 plus projects whether Ofwat is the right assurance /facilitation/ planning body – this role could easily start to distract from its core roles – and whether therefore we need some kind of system planner for water, mimicking the role of the NESO in energy.
The government also has a strong devolution/metro mayors’ agenda. There is still an open question as to how far this can play into utility infrastructure. On the one hand, regional approach in water resources have added clear value and, as work between Andy Burnham and United Utilities and between Southern Water and local authorities has shown, there are mutually supporting investments such as sustainable drainage, flood protection, water resources and wastewater clean-up. Electricity distribution companies are already having to work with local players to deliver the two-way connectivity which will typify the electricity regime of the future, and the new Regional Energy Strategic Plans (RESPs) overseen by the NESO are designed to draw together the electricity and gas companies, local government and other stakeholders to determine which investments should be prioritised. Finally, if the housing growth target is in effect delegated to local authorities, there needs at the least to be a better mechanism than we have at present for co-ordinating with utility connectivity and capacity.
But local authorities are cash strapped and will struggle to facilitate the planning demands for new infrastructure, let alone the oversight and maintenance of their own infrastructure such as many roads and flood defences. The local authority funding crisis has led to a deskilling and de-resourcing of some of the teams which are critical to the expansion of local and sub regional infrastructure – and not all development consent can be ‘sorted’ by national policy/planning statements.
In this context, it is also far from clear that the traditional utility company or local authority/metro mayor boundary offers the optimal size/focus for the new generation of infrastructure investments. (They do, of course, differ from the RESP boundaries.) Some investments could be bundled across companies to create a critical mass investible proposition – it is far from clear as mentioned above that having 16 water companies all procuring, say, smart meters will produce the lowest cost. Finally, there is a case for some of the skills to be developed collectively rather than on a company-by-company basis.
But that said, infrastructure investors and supply chain will not take kindly to increasingly disaggregated and uncoordinated projects. So as the Government has recognised there also needs to be enhanced top-down national oversight and programming.
Utilities are, finally, just one of many infrastructure areas where the balance between capital investment and maintenance and between investment and demand management, is out of kilter. The NAO and various Parliamentary Select committees have in a number of sectors pointed out forcibly that investment in both maintenance and demand management can be more cost effective than big new projects, and that there is a lack of conscious balance between these. It is becoming increasingly clear in water that capital maintenance and enhancement spend are not properly balanced. And more widely Governments across time have underinvested in behaviour change, as pointed out forcibly by the Climate Change committee in their work on the sixth Carbon budget.
The total need for infrastructure over the next 10-25 years is large. Public sector infrastructure is in many places crumbling. The decarbonisation agenda requires major new investment as does water resilience and pollution. Both supply chains and traditional investment routes have become overloaded. There is uncertainty as to how best infrastructure can work with the devolution and metro mayors’ agenda, or what this requires by way of resourcing. There is an urgent need that the new bodies and reviews which the government has announced, along with Ofwat, Ofgem and NESO, tackle the issues head on. In the meantime, some at least of the Ofwat and Ofgem approaches can and should be built upon.
This article was first published in Utility Week.
infrastructure nature based solutions Water Blog Expert viewpoints